I did think of you regarding the Benefit @jaaayp ! It could be “one of the ones!!” 🤣😁 Not completely no, but pretty close?! Stays creamy and light. I would love to get another one. The matte version of this does dry down but the colors barely showed up when I swatched them. Good if you want the most subtle of colors I think. Benefit Cosmetics Plushtint Moisturizing Matte Lip Tint 12 Purrr had the most color and tint to it but none were really a red or true pink . I had forgotten how great the mascara was too!